The Beta Quarterback

When you look at life from a psychological standpoint, you have leaders and you have followers. Well in the Taylor Blitz Times lexicon of NFL football describing the quarterback position, you have the alpha and the beta. The alpha infuses confidence in his football team through his leadership and play. His teammates are inspired through his verve, spirit, and fight which in turn raises their level of play to meet his.  You can see the confidence in their eyes when the game is tight. This is what every coach wants and covets each year in the NFL draft. He doesn’t shrink when games are on the line or when the team is up against a superior opponent.

Matt  Schaub has been a schlub in the 2013 season.

Matt Schaub has been a schlub in the 2013 season.

Then you have the beta quarterback that many teams seem to be afflicted with. He comes through with the physical gifts that scouts and coaches can see where he can improve, and can possibly sculpt a winner from. He fulfills his promise and can win you football games yet isn’t a leader. This is the guy that looks to his teammates for confidence when they’re looking to him for theirs.

Subsequently when the situations get tight or they’re up against tough teams, he shrinks before the moment.  Sure they win the games they are supposed to win but the superior opponent he needs to beat to become a champion, he will always come up short. Late game interceptions, mangled last minute drives in important games and always loses when an alpha quarterback is leading the other team. Constant big game heartbreak follows this guy….always.

Well this is how The Chancellor of Football sees the game. As you read those first two paragraphs, certain quarterbacks started to form in your mind.  One of the most unique aspect of the beta quarterback is he almost rises to prominence in the same way. Usually they are under appreciated talents that are the best of the back-up quarterbacks. Good enough to make the roster, run the scout team offense, and if we lose our starter he can pilot the ship for 3 or 4 games. Yet with the advent of complete NFL free agency, these are the guys signed after they have done well when they have relieved an injured starter. Matt Schaub was signed after performing admirably for Michael Vick in Atlanta and is the poster boy for the beta quarterback.

Tony Romo is the epitome of the Beta quarterback. On the verge of history yesterday, he threw the game away in crunch time against the Broncos yesterday.

Tony Romo is the epitome of the Beta quarterback. On the verge of history yesterday, he threw the game away in crunch time against the Broncos in a 51-48 thriller.

The Houston Texans were busy finding out the franchise quarterback they thought they had selected in David Carr just wasn’t developing. He was a shot fighter that had been beaten into submission. Too many sacks and was shrinking more by the moment when they saw a potential starter languishing on the Falcon bench. They acquired him and assembled talent around him. The team did well and when the team wasn’t ready for prime time, the thought process was: “Once he matures, he won’t throw those passes.” Yet that incessant tic never seems to leave this guy. It’s in his DNA and it becomes glaring once the rest of the team assembled with him should thrive with his leadership.

However here they are foundering when they have a healthy Brian Cushing and the NFL’s reigning NFL Defensive Player of the Year in J.J. Watt. Throw in the most prolific receiver of the last decade in 6 time Pro Bowler Andre Johnson, then perennial 1,000 yard rusher in Arian Foster. Yet here we are now that he has set an NFL record with his 4th game throwing a pick 6. Schaub is now broken.

He is well into his 30’s and we have seen the best he will ever offer the Houston Texans. This is supposed to be their year to come out of the AFC in the eyes of most pundits. Not here….the jury was already in with a verdict. In our preview: we gave a warning this should have been a point where his maturity should win big games by now. Yet it’s in his DNA and now here is this team built for a Super Bowl run that needs him to lead and ….he doesn’t have it. The Texans are not a championship football team because they have a beta quarterback that shrank again against San Fran in a 34-3 loss. Wasn’t this looked upon as a possible Super Bowl match-up before the season??

So this is the fatal flaw that afflicts both the Houston Texans and the Dallas Cowboys. In state there is a young gunslinger named Johnny Manziel that leads his team into battle against top flight competition in college. He will win games and you can see players rally around him to be better as a unit. It’s in his DNA but he may not have the typical NFL body to make it but he has the psychological make-up of an alpha quarterback. It’s his moxie that will make a team take that risk next year in the draft. Put the Cowboys and the Texans on the block for needing new quarterbacks. They don’t have an alpha and they know it. The rest of us have already come to that conclusion.

Thanks for reading and please share the article.

6 thoughts on “The Beta Quarterback

  1. It’s an opinionated article that steers far away from real facts. Was Peyton Manning a Beta QB for the first 8 years of his career and then became a Alpha for 1 year and then became a Beta again. Was Elway a Beta QB for 15 years and then became an Alpha his last two. This article is based on hatred and that’s it. Why was Romo and Schaub the only ones talked about, do you not like Texas? Lol, why was Phillip Rivers and Matt Ryan not talked about, I mean Eli has 2 Super Bowls, guess he was an Alpha those two years but when his team got bad he became and Beta. Stupid stupid stupid. It’s the team!!


    • We can talk about all of those quarterbacks. Hatred?? LOL No these two quarterbacks had just lost in two very high profile ways. One plays for the Texans who many pundits picked to represent the AFC in the Super Bowl. Yet he’s setting records for interceptions returned for touchdowns and his fans cheered when he got injured. Tony Romo demonstrated that fatal flaw thathas chased him his whole career. Game on the line against Denver and throws a big interception. The entire country was watching. Speaking of hating, you slung a few arrows ar Eli Manning yet he’s holding two Super Bowl rings. Of course irs the team but why do they have records for quarterbacks in terms of wins and losses then?? You must be from Texas…


  2. Reblogged this on Taylor Blitz Times and commented:

    Then you have Tony Romo. Sigh…. Do you realize he was on the cusp of NFL history?? Had he driven the Cowboys to the Bronco 32 yard line on that last drive, he would have broken Norm Van Brocklin’s 554 yards passing record that has stood for 7 decades!! Is it unfair to judge him as a “choke artist” as many fans have come to think of him as?? At what point does the Dallas Cowboy defense need to come up and make a play?? Yet the truth of the matter is Romo threw the critical interception at the critical time. It will be his history no matter what he has or will accomplish. The path of the Beta quarterback.


  3. Reblogged this on UnSportsMenMic and commented:
    I agree with the Alpha and Beta argument, I don’t think Romo is a Beta but neither an Alpha. I think Romo is Bepha or an Alpeta. Let’s not under mind the fact that Manning let Romo back in the game with a bad interception. We wouldn’t be talking about Romo last minute int if Manning did let the back in tha game while leading 35-20. Or the fact that its a complete blow out if not for Romo playing great. Or lastly that the Alpha in Peyton Manning is 9-11 in the playoffs, and got a ring hugely on the strength of Bob Sanders coming back to boost the Defense. Remember we used to say Peyton couldn’t win the big one (in Tenn. and Indy) and he is an “Alpha” and I guarantee this playoffs the pressure will mount on Manning too and he will look like a Bepha or an Alpeta. Great Article!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.