Top Ten Quarterbacks Ever!

The position of quarterback is unique in the sports world. No other position commands more respect, need to process information in a more condensed timeframe, or expected to lead his team with his play and demeanor like that of a quarterback. Point guards in basketball call out the plays but the team is defined by their big men and scoring comes from either forward positions or the shooting guard.  Pitchers share pitch calls with the catcher and the relief pitcher finishes a tight game to help the pitcher get a win.  The quarterback has to do all of these things which include last second touchdown drives in a two-minute drill. He doesn’t get to turn the game over to a reliever.  He is easily the central nervous system of the team and without his efforts they’re paralyzed to move the ball or win.

The greatest quarterbacks ever master all of these qualities.  The art of the pre-snap read, then to decipher what the defense is doing in under 2 seconds and where his teammate are going to be, while making the right throw.  All the while 4 to 5 fire-breathing defenders are closing in to do bodily harm.  So what makes the great ones, who stand amidst the masses, and calmly deliver the football?  There are all time quarterbacks who are winners and championship teams whose quarterback went along for the ride. The all time greats willed their team to victory through their play.  Here is my all time list.

  1.  Joe Montana: First 3 time Super Bowl MVP while quarterbacking 4 Super Bowl Champions in San Francisco. Performed the signature play of a dynasty with “The Catch” in the 1981 NFC Championship. Beginning in 1983 as a starting QB he led 10 straight teams to the playoffs (49ers ‘83-’90, Chiefs 93 & 94). Ushered in the West Coast offense as a staple while leading more than 30 4th quarter come from behind drives.  Had 8 3,000 yard seasons including his last.  Although 1989 was statistically his best season, in 11 games in 1987 he threw for his career high of 31 TDs.  The best.

  2. Johnny Unitas: Frank DeFord once said that “All quarterbacks today are descendants of Johnny Unitas.”  The benchmark every quarterback is still be measured by.  Retired with more than 40,000 yards passing, 3 NFL Championships, a 4th with a Super Bowl III loser.  Engineered the first two minute drill in the last minutes of the 1958 NFL Championship.   His leadership, demeanor, throwing style, and playing style molded the next two generations of youngsters with how the game should be played.  Still holds the equivalent of Joe DiMaggio’s 56 game hitting streak with 47 straight games with a touchdown pass.  I think Unitas feat is greater.  Had 11 seasons with over 2500 yards passing.

  3. Otto Graham and Paul Brown

    Otto Graham: The first quintessential winner who was part of a system (Paul Brown’s) that led Cleveland to 10 straight championship appearances. From 1946-1949 the Cleveland Browns ruled the AAFC winning all for league titles.  Then once merged into the NFL: 1950-1955 the Cleveland Browns were in every championship game winning 3 of them while battling the Detroit Lions and Cleveland Rams.  The first quarterback on a Wheaties Box and Mapo Oatmeal commercials so youngsters could “be like Mike.” Statistics don’t measure the man and what he meant for his football team as a leader.

  4. Brett Favre: Winningest quarterback ever. Embodied the epitome of a gunslinger and was durable. He broke the record of most consecutive starts for a QB in October of 1999 at 114 straight and kept it going until he retired after 2011 with over 290, nearly tripling it. First MVP of the league in 3 consecutive seasons.  He brought the Packer’s franchise out of the doldrums of the NFL and made them winners in Super Bowl XXXI.  Favre threw for a conference record for TD passes with 38 and 39 respectively in 95 and 96. Would go on to throw for the most yards & TDs in history.  A gunslinger from the word go, his first taste of NFL action in 1992, he replaced Don Majkoski and hit Kittrick Taylor with a game winning TD with under a minute to go.  A flair for the dramatic.  Had 1 stretch to begin 1999 where he engineered 4 straight 4th quarter comebacks in successive weeks with under 2 minutes to go.   One of a kind.

  5. Our #4 Brett Favre and #5 Dan Marino

    Dan Marino: A completely transcendent performer with a quick release that burst onto the scene in 1983.  His record breaking year of 1984 was the single greatest passing performance ever.  He shattered the single season record for TDs in a season at 48, blowing by the old record of 36.  He became the first to throw for 5,000 yards in a season.  Also threw for 44TDs in 1986.  His attitude and throwing motion struck fear in defenses for most of his career.   His undermanned Dolphins never won the Super Bowl during his tenure. Went on to throw for 61,000 yards and 420TDs over his career.  His release (on film) was under 9 frames when the typical frame rate for most QBs was 12 – 13.  So when you see film of someone almost sacking him, had they been someone else it would have been. By the way, it was Marino who has the most 4th quarter comebacks at 36 to John Elway’s 34…just so you know.

  6. Tom Brady: A 3-time Super Bowl champion who quarterbacked the Patriots to team of the decade status in the ‘00s.  A technical quarterback with an emotional streak that went from being a serviceable player to one of the best ever. He holds the single season record for TDs at 50, directed the only 16-0 regular season, and still in his prime can achieve another milestone or two.  Entering the latter stages in his career and still writing his history.

  7. Terry Bradshaw: The number one draft pick in 1970 who became the first 4 time Super Bowl winner and MVP of the 13th and 14th editions.  He led the Steelers to 4 championships in 6 years.  Had a rocket arm and was a tough runner early in his career.  Became a more complete quarterback as the Steelers attack took to the air in 1978 with the rules changes.  Played big in big games.  He iced Super Bowl IX with a TD to Larry Brown and had his first 300 yard game in Super Bowl XIII while setting the TD pass record in Super Bowl’s at 4.  Held the Super Bowl record for longest TD (to Stallworth75 yards) and nearly matched it with a game winning TD pass to Stallworth at 73yds in Super Bowl XIV against the Los Angeles Rams.

  8. Roger Staubach: Tremendous quarterback who began as a scrambler, evolved into a true pocket passer and retired as the highest rated quarterback ever in 1979.  Was efficient and led the Cowboys to 8 playoff appearances in 9 years. A fearless leader who brought Dallas from behind 23 times in the final two minutes or in overtime.  Roger the Dodger morphed into Captain Comeback and was one of sport’s biggest icons.

  9. John Elway: The rocket arm quarterback who brashly demanded a trade before he ever played a game.  The heir to Staubach’s comeback mantle by producing 30 wins in the final two minutes or in overtime. Produced some of the most breathtaking drives in playoff history.  Passed for numerous 3,000 yard seasons and won a record 5 conference championships including 2 Super Bowl championships.  Had one of the strongest arms in NFL history and the architect of 34 4th quarter comebacks and many of the breath taking variety.

  10.  Steve Young: Greatest left hander in history.  Replaced Joe Montana and led the NFL in passer rating 4 straight years, made 3 NFC Championships, and won one Super Bowl during that era.  He went on to set a record for passing efficiency in 1994 and led the 49ers to the playoffs 7 straight seasons and 4 berths in the NFC Championship Game.  He was also a fearless and rugged runner.  A weapon that allowed the 49ers to play offense 11 on 11 since teams rarely account for the quarterback.   Saved many drives with his ability to run. 

So who’s your top ten?!?!

5 thoughts on “Top Ten Quarterbacks Ever!

  1. This is a great list of top 10 all time QB’s and I agree with it as it has top QB’s that played in their respected era’s …….and the comment about Dan Fouts not being on the list I have to say it is right to not have him on this list. He would be on a top 10 list of QB’s to not make it to a Super Bowl. Moreso, I agree with Mr. Taylor’s comment, those years in his prime (1979-1982) were his best years and he was more a product of the system that Don Coryell had in place as well as the talent he had around him on the offensive side of the ball.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I almost agree with your list except Farve would be #10-he ruined his credibility when he went to the Vikings. One part of a great QB is talent and the other is loyality-when he went to the Vikings itwas a slap in the face to the Packers and he was horendous……he didn’t know when to quit. Still believe the #49ers produce great QB’s and am saddened to see Marino’s records being broken…..loved the Marino-Elway rivalty

    Liked by 1 person

  3. This 10 QB list has it all. Overrated player’s (Tom Brady). Players that just flat out don’t match up Physically with the players today (Otto Graham). And Guys who just flat out don’t Belong (Can you with a straight face say that Peyton Manning is NOT better than Terry Bradshaw or Roger Staubach???) I Have question, what is the criteria??? IS it stats, championships or a combination of both?? According to the trend I guess Big Ben will Push Young off this list when he gets his 3rd ring in a couple of weeks. Bottom Line Brady, Young, Graham and Bradshaw flat out don’t belong on this list. Unitas is ranked too high. Elway is waaaaaaay too low!! And where in the hell is Dan Fouts?? I just scratch my head at this list.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Its a combination of things….excellent play, influence and championships. When it comes to Dan Fouts he was the first to pass over 4000 yards more than once but really only had 4 peak years from 1979-1982. After that he was a decent quarterback and thats it. The trips to the 1980 and 1981 AFC Championship Games is all he really accomplished. The memory makes people think like he was lighting people up his whole career. Young was great for an entire decade…came in and led the NFL in 1991 and was 3-1 and leading the league when his career ended in 1999…he led the league in passing five times and berths in 4 NFC Championship games and won a Super Bowl. Had a Super Bowl MVP to boot. Dan Fouts doesn’t come close to knocking Steve Young from #10 by no stretch of the imagination!!

      Peyton Manning has had several seasons with a ton of interceptions but they constantly give him a pass. The last two years he’s thrown for 16 & 17 interceptions and had that been Brett Favre we would have heard about it loudly. His three seasons of over 20 interceptions and another at 19 picks in 2002. He’s been media darling (ed) into a 4 time MVP. He’s thrown countless interceptions in 4th quarter of playoff games and got pick sixed out of Super Bowl XLIV. They GAVE him a co MVP with Steve McNair who had a career year, when in fact Manning threw for 19 interceptions. THAT WAS WRONG! He’s been totally overrated his entire career. I also remember his bumbling playoff losses to New England and that absolute 41-0 trouncing to the New York Jets in a wildcard game also. Peyton Manning is not in my top ten ever and barely makes my top 5 contemporary quarterbacks at 4.

      Elway made big plays but wasn’t a spectacular quarterback and he still got run over in those first three Super Bowls. He also had some high interception seasons and rarely threw for more than 20 TDs in a season. Roethlisberger is like this…makes big plays but not enough to make my top ten all time quarterbacks…nope


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.